The Best Toddler Tested Catholic Christmas Gifts for 2026

A boy and a girl sit on the floor in front of the Christmas tree opening presents. Hopefully their parents picked some of the best Catholic Christmas gifts!

The annual Christmas gift shopping can be daunting. To help you find more joy this Christmas season, here’s a list of some of my favorite Catholic Christmas gifts for kids—tested by my daughter!


When the Christmas season comes into sight, I always tell myself that this is the year I am really going to be intentional with my time. I’m going to get ahead of all the planning, preparation, and shopping so that I can be more present during the days that matter and take time to immerse myself in the spirituality of Advent.

As all the other parents reading will know, it hardly ever happens like that. Managing all the demands of the holidays—from family commitments, community engagements, and, of course, shopping—can leave you feeling drained and as if you let a very important liturgical season pass you buy.

If you’re like me, the gift wish lists are often the thing that I get the most hung up on. Not only is it hard to decide on the best gifts, but I find myself questioning if the items in question are in alignment with my goals as a Catholic parent. I spend countless hours reading reviews, watching videos, and going back and forth in my head about what to get for my two-year-old daughter Evangeline (Evie for short) to the point that all my other responsibilities get short shrift.

Sound familiar?

Well, no more! The first annual Catholic Echo Christmas Gift Guide is here!

To make things easier for you, I enlisted sweet little Evie and reached out to some Catholic stores for their top Catholic Christmas gifts for 2026. When they arrived, Evie gave me her feedback (such as it is) and helped me give my honest recommendations from one parent to another.

Without any further ado, here are some of my favorite Catholic Christmas gifts for kids this year. Make sure to get that shopping done early!

Shining Light Dolls

Chantal Baros founded Shining Light Dolls over a decade ago when she found herself frustrated while shopping for a baptism gift for her nephew. She found there was a lack of “Catholic play-based learning toys,” objects designed for children that they could really sink their teeth—and grabby little hands—into.

While “dolls” is in the company name, the company has expanded to include a wide range of Montessori-style toys, books, games, and activity sets that make for great Catholic Christmas gifts for kids of all ages. Here are some of the highlights:

The Jesse Tree (Magnetic Tree and Book Bundle)

Among all the items I received for this review, this became one of my favorites, and my daughter absolutely loved it. Even though she might be a bit young to engage with it fully, I appreciated all the different skills that this set targets, and its something that kids will get more and more out of as they get older.

The Jesse Tree is basically an interactive advent calendar. Kids go through the book day-by-day and open a flap to reveal an image and a brief story that teaches Salvation history. They then find a corresponding magnet and put it on the tree in order from 1-25.  

Evie immediately lunged for the book and proudly declared “mine!” But when she realized that the pictures in the book matched up with magnets in the bag, she became obsessed.

I loved that she could play with each element of the set separately, but intuitively grasped that they worked together. Even though she won’t really appreciate the Bible story attached to the images, she was building up her speech skills, pattern recognition, learning numbers, and practicing fine motor skills. This held her attention for a good 15-20 minutes, which is basically a five-star review for a toddler.

I can easily see this toy being a hit with kids even younger than her and all the way up to around five or six, when she’ll be able to understand the stories behind each symbol. But by then, this will have helped her learn about the meaning of Christmas and the joy of an Advent tradition that she will (hopefully) take with her for the rest of her life.

Not only is it a great toy for kids, but it works as a décor item as well—the tree comes with a wall hook for easy hanging. I’d recommend this for any family with young kids—just remember to get it early so they can start on December 1st!

Magna Missal – Magnetic Playscene

A child plays with the Magna Missal toy from Shining Light Dolls, one of our picks for best Catholic Christmas gifts for kids.

I never thought I’d see the day that I was nerding out over a kids toy, but here we are. This was another 10/10 toy from Shining Light Dolls from both a play and design perspective.

The Magna Missal is a foldable magnetic book featuring a mass scene with priests, parishioners, and sacred church objects such as an altar, baptismal font, and more. A magnetic sheet holds the magnets and serves as a puzzle, with markers below helping kids recognize where shapes fit.

This was great for my daughter, who loves to pop the magnets out of the sheet, put them on the scene, and fit them back into place with equal measure. It’s also slim, light, and relatively quiet as compared to busy books with Velcro!

Note: this item does have small parts that constitute a choking hazard and Shining Light Dolls recommends it for kids aged three and up. While my daughter is only two, she never sticks things in her mouth so I felt it was okay for her.

Overall, I found this a cleverly designed, highly efficient toy that offers kids multiple ways to play. It will stay relevant for years as they enjoy tactile interaction before recognizing the objects or learning the words.

Blessed Mother Rag Doll – Our Lady of Grace

A girl holds the Blessed Mother rag doll from Shining Light toys, one of our picks for best Catholic Christmas gifts in 2026.

I must preface this by saying that Evie is not a doll girl—like, not at all. My guess is that she knows exactly how much work she is, and is wholly uninterested in taking on that level of responsibility. I admire her self-knowledge!

So, while these dolls didn’t really interest my daughter, I think most kids will adore them. They are beautiful objects, designed and crafted with care, and there are tons of options to choose from—though the Blessed Mother is my top choice because you can get her on her own, with a baby Jesus and strap-on carrier, or as a nativity set with St. Joseph.

I really appreciate toys that bridge the gap between play and real life, and I could see kids enjoying putting these dolls in a nativity set or taking them out and playing with them for a while—it involves them in doing the decorations, learning about the Christmas story, and honoring the Holy Family.

While I think the dolls skew more towards girl’s toys, there are several male figures available too, including the aforementioned St. Joseph, Jesus, and St. Carlo Acutis, which young boys will probably prefer.

St. Lucia Buns (Lussekatter) & Swedish Glögg Wooden Play Food Set

Wooden toy set of mugs and baked buns from Shining Light Dolls, one of our picks for best Catholic Christmas gifts this year.

While my daughter isn’t into dolls, this play food and drink set was definitely up her alley! She is just starting to get into imaginary play and playing tea party (with stuffed animals, but definitely not dolls!), so this toy was perfect for her developmental stage.

First of all, I loved that the toys were wood—her other tea set is made out of some kind of cheap metal which, while better than plastic, still worries me! Plus, they were colorful, distinctly textured and durable—all wins in my book!

This set of saffron buns and glögg mugs are designed to celebrate the Feast of St. Lucy on December 13, but they will make perfect Christmas gifts to enjoy throughout the winter months and beyond. You can recreate the Swedish tradition with your kids, wherein the little ones dress in white and candle-lit crowns (maybe just go for regular crowns) and serve the buns and drinks to their families in the early morning.

While this toy definitely leans towards older kids with longer attention spans, my daughter loved putting the cinnamon sticks and star anise in the mugs, the orange slices on the rim, and taking a big pretend drink before insisting I did the same. I think this is another toy that kids will enjoy at a young age and continue to play with in different ways as they get older.

And if your kids are really into play cooking, they have a whole Mini Catholic Kitchen set with much more!

Christmas Nativity Memory Match Game

A child flipping cards from the Christmas Nativity Memory Match game from Shining Light Dolls, a good stocking stuffer from our list of the best Catholic Christmas gifts.

This little game will make a perfect stocking stuffer with big returns. And would any good list of Catholic Christmas gifts forget about stockings?

The set consists of 13 pairs of cards with images from the Nativity story, including the three wise men, animals, and baby Jesus. Nothing complicated here, but it’s a perfect way to focus your kid for 10 minutes while still incorporating your faith!

Younger kids like my daughter will enjoy matching images (working on their pattern recognition skills) while older kids will take it a step further and flip the cards over and try and match them from memory. You can even make it a competitive game where one person scores a point for every match and turns it over to the other player if they miss. Plus, their light weight makes them perfect for keeping them entertained in the pews!

It’s simple, but sometimes simple toys are the best!         

My Book of Catholic Prayers

The cover of Shining Light Dolls' "My Book of Catholic Prayers" featuring a dove and a flower on a blue background.

Another perfect stocking stuffer, Evie has practically worn the covers off this book. We actually got it as a baptism gift a couple of years ago, and Evie has loved it ever since.

A colorful collection of 14 essential Catholic prayers (including the Our Father, Hail Mary, Memorare, and others) this book is the perfect size for tiny hands! A lot of books are too big for her to manage on her own, but she can easily carry and flip through the 3×6 pages all by herself.

Seeing my daughter tote this into Mass wearing her Sunday Best just kills me! Highly recommended for kids at almost any age.

The Little Rose Shop

Founded in 2014 by Raquel Rose, The Little Rose Shop began as a way for Raquel to keep her daughter busy during Mass and has only continued to bloom in the 12 years since.

Raquel’s life turned upside down when she became pregnant at 21, facing the challenges of single motherhood while still in college. Despite feeling pressured to terminate the pregnancy, Raquel chose life, the beginning of a story of reconversion and dedication to her faith.

Wanting to take her daughter to Mass but feeling the all-too-familiar challenge of bringing a young child to church, Raquel decided to make homemade quiet books. When she realized how much her daughter enjoyed playing with them—not to mention how much she enjoyed making them—she figured other moms would find them useful too! And thus, the business was born.

Now married with three more kids, Little Rose Shop has sprouted in new directions too. Their entire collection includes clothing for kids and adults, home décor and tableware—so while you’re shopping for kids toys, you might be able to find some good Catholic Christmas gifts for Mom and Dad to enjoy too!

Peek-a-boo Saints 2

Little Rose Shop's "Peek-a-boo Saints 2" book sitting amongst other kids' toys.

Would any list of Catholic Christmas gifts be complete without showing a little love to our saints?

The follow-up to Little Rose Shop’s award winning (and perpetually wait-listed) original, this interactive board book tickled Evie’s inquisitive toddler brain in all the right ways.

These peek-a-book books are an improvement over standard flip-books because of the different ways kids can interact with them. Instead of just opening a flap the same way ten times, this book has spinners, sliders, and pull-out pages all in one. The joy of seeing a little smiling saint pop up brought out multiple of those soul-healing toddler giggles.

I also think this has some good longevity. You could easily introduce this to kids as young as four-months just like any other book. As their fine-motor skills progress, they will be able to enjoy it for themselves. And finally, when they’re ready to start reading, this would be a great place to start, giving it a whole new life.

Evie was thoroughly engrossed in this book for a good ten minutes, which is quite good for a book of this size! I’d happily recommend Peek-a-boo Saints 2 for all kids under five.

One note—the interactive bits needed a bit of warming up before they would move easily. Parents may want to go through the book a few times to make sure everything is working smoothly to avoid any tantrum-inducing friction.

Catholic ABC Board Book

Pages from Little Rose Shop's "Catholic ABC Board Book" showing the "G" and "H" pages with flaps and traceable letters.

Something about seeing my daughter point to a crucifix and say “cwoss” just kills me. “YES!”, I want to shout. “That’s what it’s all about! Jesus loves you!”

To avoid freaking her out, I restrain myself. But the point is, this book is a top-tier gift for any new Catholic parents. It functions as well as any standard ABC book, of course, but also helps develop that deep recognition of sacred symbols, objects and themes that is so important for instilling a life-long love for our faith in our kids.

Again, this book has some longevity. The high contrast letters will stand out for newborns, while the flaps will interest kids from one to two years old. It also features recessed letters for slightly older kids to practice tracing letters.

This didn’t hold Evie’s attention for quite as long, but I think that’s because she’s used to lift-the-flap books and doesn’t yet grasp the letter-tracing element. When she’s ready to start learning her letters, I’ll be bringing this back out—there’s no place else I’d rather start.

Where is Jesus Quiet Book

Cover of the "Where is Jesus" quiet book from Little Rose Shop. Gold cover with a sun and cloud stitched on.

The quiet book is an absolutely essential companion for any parents struggling to make it through Mass with a child that’s through the newborn stage but not quite old enough to resist the temptation to chuck all their toys just to hear the sound.

What I particularly enjoyed about this book was the fact that it was focused around finding Jesus on each page—most other interactive books just have different textures and images to keep a kid’s attention, but this one goes a step further and has them searching for something in particular and building pattern-recognition skills.

It also teaches an important theological lesson for slightly older kids: on the final page, Jesus is revealed behind images of all sorts of people—an elderly person, a disabled person, and more.

That really adds to the longevity. The youngest kids will enjoy the textures and flaps, toddlers will enjoy searching for the image of Jesus, and older kids will understand the symbolism.

I would recommend this for kids as young as three months all the way up to around five, with the expectation that it will phase in and out over the years—there are countless toys that Evie has rediscovered from her newborn days that she enjoys in a new way, and I think this will be one of them.

Catholic Sprouts

Catholic Sprouts was founded in 2018 by Nancy Bandzuch, a mom of six and entrepreneur who often felt like she wasn’t doing all she could to teach her kids about the faith. She came up with a clever idea—she started recording short faith-focused podcasts for her kids during their nap time. When she realized she couldn’t be the only mom who felt this way, she started releasing her podcast publicly, and it has since been downloaded millions of times. Thus, Catholic Sprouts was born!

Catholic Sprouts definitely leans more towards teaching resources rather than straight up toys, but there are still plenty of options that would make for good Catholic Christmas gifts for kids of all ages, even for the teenagers (God help me when we reach that stage!)

Adoration Coloring Book

Photo of Catholic Sprouts' "Adoration Coloring Book" with crayons strewn in front. Cover shows a full color cartoon picture of Jesus.

As soon as Evie started reaching for pens and scribbling on spare pieces of paper, I started looking for Catholic coloring books, and this one from Catholic Sprouts did not disappoint!

Featuring over 50 pages with Jesus, Mary, and many different saints, what I especially loved about this coloring book was the inclusion of colorable quotes that presented an opportunity not only to read while we drew, but even taught me some important lessons! Plus, while Evie was scribbling lines and circles on the figures, my Type-A brain enjoyed meticulously filling in the letters at the same time.

I also loved how detailed and distinct each image was. Each saint is depicted with significant symbols from their stories that will really help them stand out in your kiddo’s mind.

Also—and parents will know what I’m talking about—the paper was top-notch quality. Nothing is worse than getting a new coloring book for your kid only for them to be frustrated that either the colors don’t show up well on the paper, or their crayons don’t draw smoothly, or only work with markers, etc.

This was a very high-quality coloring book with gorgeous designs and plenty of Catholic theology to boot! Kids of any age will enjoy this—but for the younger ones make sure they have washable resources to use!

Mysteries of the Rosary Board Book Set

The books from the Mysteries of the Rosary Board Book Set from Catholic Sprouts, with two rosaries laying on either side.

As someone who has endeavored to say the rosary with my daughter every single day, I really wish I had learned about this book set sooner!

When she was a newborn, it was so easy! I’d just take her outside, hold her in my arms, and say the prayers while I stared into those beautiful blue eyes of hers. Nowadays, it often becomes an all-day effort—we say a couple of decades during breakfast, another one before nap time, and then finish it in the bathtub when I realized we never did the rest.

A daily rosary is not only important for all Catholics, but face-to-face talking with newborns has been proven to accelerate their language learning and comprehension of nonverbal cues. I find it difficult to just talk for no reason (as I’m sure many parents do) so I decided I would “talk” to her by saying the rosary. I figured this would not only provide all the same benefits as any other speech, but would also familiarize her with our prayers and develop a sense of emotional attachment not only to me but to the act of saying the rosary.

It’s too early to tell if that has gone as well as I’d hoped, but I’m sure she would have enjoyed it even more if she had these books earlier on!

The books include instructions on praying the rosary, the names of the mystery (as well as a simplified definition that kids will more easily understand) and an image of the mystery. Giving Evie something to hold and interact with while we were praying together would have helped further solidify the purpose of the prayers, and maybe helped keep her focused for longer.

However, I think these books may have a bit of a dead-zone in terms of when kids will get the most out of them. The bright colors will be sure to engage babies as they develop the fine motors skills needed for turning the pages, and they will make for good early readers when she starts learning her letters.

From two to four, though, there’s not a lot for her to engage with. She’s not old enough to understand the words, but she is not young enough to stay engaged with a simple board book for a long period. She’s looking for things with flaps, textures, or maybe even music and sounds.

That’s not to say there’s anything wrong with this set—like I said, I wish I’d found this sooner. As such, I’d recommend it for kids between three months and two years old and kids from three and up who are able to actually say the prayers and have more understanding of what they’re looking at.

Be A Heart

Be A Heart began as a simple blog by founder Erica Tighe Campbell in 2010 where she wrote about her time spent volunteering in areas deeply affected by poverty in Brazil, which she describes as a transformative but emotionally challenging experience.

Upon returning to the US in 2012, Campbell moved to Brooklyn where she suffered from depression and a spiritual “darkness” for a time before finding God through an Alcoholics Anonymous program. During her recovery, Campbell practiced calligraphy to help handle her anxiety, which eventually led her to start a calligraphy and stationery design business in Los Angeles.

Realizing she could have an impact with her talent, Campbell decided to design her own products, rooted in her Catholic spirituality. Over the years, Be A Heart has grown to include beautifully designed home décor, holiday decorations, stationery, and, of course, toys! It’s a great option for Catholic Christmas gifts, for kids and adults alike.

Mary on the Mantel (Full Set)

Photo of the Mary Ragdoll and the Mary on the Mantel book from Be A Heart's Mary on the Mantel set.

Disclaimer: Unfortunately, this item did not arrive in time for me to test it in person, so I cannot vouch for its quality, nor can I record Evie’s input as to the fun factor. However, as a dad, I was so drawn to this gift I just wanted to include it anyways because it hit so many key factors in what I would consider for my daughter and home!

Mary on the Mantel is an interactive Christmas tradition that will delight kids and parents alike. Designed as a sort of Catholic alternative to the “Elf on the Shelf” game, the set features a Virgin Mary ragdoll, an attachable pregnant belly, and a baby Jesus ragdoll and carrier that can be moved around the house every night as your kiddos sleep. In the morning, they’ll love running around the house looking for where she will reappear.

The set also comes with 60 cards of “small acts of kindness” for your children to do each day, plus a book that explains Mary and Joseph’s journey to prepare for the birth of Jesus and a map of the Holy Land to help them understand just how monumental that undertaking was.

If the idea of placing Mary creatively around the house seems like a bit much for you, fret not—the set also comes with a guide for parents for ideas on what Mary can do around the house.

Like I mentioned, I didn’t get to try this personally, but this is the exact kind of thing that makes me salivate as a parent: a “toy” that both kids and parents interact with, that tells a story, and builds a tradition all in one. It’s hard to beat that!

Just note that this is really more of an Advent gift than a Christmas gift, so you’ll want to get it ordered early to enjoy this year.

Merry Christmas from the Catholic Echo!

I hope this review of some of the best Catholic Christmas gifts has helped get your juices flowing for all that pesky shopping, but this list is by no means comprehensive! There are tons of additional options from each of the shops above, and many more shops that I couldn’t even get to, so be sure to get out there and explore and help support our Catholic brothers and sisters this Christmas season!

And above all, I hope this makes it easier for you to get the to-do list done early so you can spend more time with the Lord this advent!


Find more news, events, and insights at The Catholic Echo.

Share To Social Media

Picture of Collin Vogt

Collin Vogt

Related Stories

Stay up to date with all new things happening at the Diocese of Youngstown. Subscribe to our Newsletter here.

Cookie policy
We use our own and third party cookies to allow us to understand how the site is used and to support our marketing campaigns.